The Bake Buddy Cookie S’mores Experiment

I haven’t really done many kitchen experiments on this blog as of yet, since I always get excited to bake that I tend to forget to document the process. It feels like a hassle sometimes to have to set up the camera (even with me just using my mobile phone cam) with all the settings to toggle with, in addition to keeping the ingredients aligned while you fiddle to get the money shot. But I wanted to do something nice today, so I tried my hand at a simple cookie mix.

What I had lying around the house was a container of Bake Buddy Cookie S’mores mix. Bake Buddy is a company that’s been making it’s rounds at bazaars and selling cans of cookie mixes and ready-made cookies. Mine happened to be the Cookie S’mores.

Here’ s a photo of the original container with all the ingredients inside:

Cookie S’mores!

The concept is attractive, wouldn’t you say? It’s a time-saver if you don’t have to haul your butt to the grocery store to gather  ingredients. If you’re not much of a regular baker, you drastically reduce the risk of having a stock of too many ingredients at home that’ll end up stale and expired.

Layers of Ingredients

All the dry ingredients are inside the nifty package, so you only need to have 2-3 wet ingredients at hand. I’m seeing/guessing the inside contains all-purpose flour, baking soda, brown sugar, salt, chocolate chips, and small marshmallows. The lid has instructions pasted on and calls for some butter, an egg, and some vanilla.

“The Literature”

The mise en place is simple and can be done in 2 bowls, since the instructions basically state that you dump everything in, once the wet ingredients have been mixed properly. But I decided to separate everything for the sake of showing the step-by-step. You’ll also need a mixer, eggbeater, or whisk. –I’ll explain why later.

Mise en place: Baking tray lined with silpat or parchment, butter, egg, vanilla, 2 bowls (1 big, 1 small), and your spatula

The big bowl is for the dough, while the small container is for the marshmallows. You’ll need to take them out first, or they’ll get battered with all the mixing.

Scoop out the mallows!

The lid says to mix all the wet ingredients, but I wouldn’t advise anyone to use the butter as is. From experience, fresh-from-the-fridge butter is too hard and will not incorporate well (if at all) with the other wet ingredients. You have to melt the butter, so that you could whisk everything together smoothly.

Melt the butter over a low fire

Since this is a kitchen experiment, I decided to soften the butter only slightly in order to show the effect of using it cold.

Butter still has solids

Vanilla extract

I attacked it with an electric beater, which resulted in a lumpy mixture that does not look appetizing. Then I added the rest of the container’s contents in one go.

Chips and Lumps


This is the part where you get rid of the whisk or egg beater and start working the dough with a scraper or spatula. I would even suggest you get your hands “dirty” to produce a fine dough with no lumps of flour or sugar. Using your hands on the dough will also help soften up the butter if you initially had it in lumps.

Mixed using my spatula

Refined “handy” work

And while the recipe suggests making 2 trays of cookies, I preferred 1 tray of big, chewy cookies. Using an electronic scale, I measured out 40 grams each  (more or less) of dough before shaping them into balls with an ice cream scoop and a spoon. I got a dozen 40-gram dough balls out of it.

Finally, you top them off with the marshmallows and bake them in the oven at 190C (350F). I went with 13-14 minutes instead of the suggested 8-12, since my product was larger yet I wanted it to come out very chewy.



The result was a little on the flat side. –Perhaps it lacks baking soda, or the leavener in the can wasn’t so active anymore. But I got the soft, chewy cookies I so desired. Flavor-wise, they were good. I’m a sucker for the melted brown sugar in a chocolate chip cookie, though this one came off as a little too sweet what with the marshmallows and chocolate chips fighting for attention.

Mission Accomplished

A can of mix in this flavor comes to around Php350. I love the novelty of it, though that same Php350 will get you more of the same ingredients in the grocery if you don’t mind making the trip. That said, I find it more of a gift item than something to get for yourself to do at home.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s